Sometimes, conversations on social media can be productive. People can respectfully discuss a topic, and share thoughts and ideas. In honor of that, and to bring light to an important topic, below is the discussion I had on Facebook. I've replaced the names of the other guys with clever pseudonyms. (For a lengthier discussion of the Abbas speech, you can check out this recent article that I read)
One More Time: The Law of Return isn’t Racist
It’s hard for a Jew who grew up in Brooklyn to admit, but sometimes, it isn’t worth arguing. It really does depend on the circumstance. Case in point: tour guides. Sure, I overhear lots of them walking around Jerusalem. And they often make odd mistakes or misrepresentations. While putting in my own two cents is tempting, there is little point. They’ll probably be defensive, and convince the tourists that you are a dufus once you walk away. Hence my strict “no arguing with tour guides” policy.
On Kurds as Dhimmi
There’s a well known historical observation that antisemitism transformed in modernity. Crusaders and Nazis attacked Jews for different reasons. In the middle ages, Christians saw Jews as “other” and persecuted them for rejecting Jesus. As Europe secularized, antipathy towards the Jews became based on ethnicity and race rather than theology. With this shift, Jews themselves lost the escape route of conversion. Racial antisemitism in the Reich leads to a “final solution” in a way that never occurred to Popes or Feudal lords.
The Partition Experiments
This coming April, we will celebrate the 70th anniversary of the birth of the modern Jewish state. Before that happens, we’ll pass by a less celebrated date. November 29th will mark 70 years since the United Nations partition plan. We’ve seen the pictures of the celebrations after the vote passed. I’m pretty sure there isn’t a city in Israel that doesn’t have a “29th of November” street.
The Paradigm Shift
Fair warning: My first example won’t be good.
Sometimes teaching is hard, because some types of learning are hard. There are deep foundational ideas that can be heard, and even understood, but not integrated well into a person’s identity. Some bigger ideas need to be digested over time and experience. Teachers who want their students to achieve a deeper functional understanding of certain ideas may seek shortcuts. But they will probably not find them. Understanding an idea does not quickly create the full paradigm shift in thinking, no matter how deeply desired that outcome.
Fail to the Chief?
“Is he/she good for Israel/the Jews?” It's probably the question most frequently asked by my students about any particular non-Israeli politician. I’m not surprised. Having grown up in the American Jewish community, I am very familiar with this pass/fail litmus test. A foreign leader is either good or bad for Israel.
Let's Fix This
Are you finding that your conversations and newsfeeds are clogged by partisan miscommunication? Are people yelling past each other instead of talking to each other?
The 5 Stages of Middle East Grief
Why so noisy?
Is your newsfeed still buzzing? Mine is. A week after the UNSC Resolution 2334, the American abstention, and the Kerry speech, there is still plenty of freaking out to be seen. No matter where one is on the political spectrum, there is no shortage of emoting.